The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner
4.5 / 5 Stars
310 Pages
Originally Published in 2021
Finished Reading on May 13, 2024
I’ll admit it: I’m a sucker for stories that weave the past and present together. When I picked up The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner, I was immediately drawn to its mysterious premise. A secret apothecary dispensing poisons to help women free themselves from oppressive men? Count me in.
As I sipped my third cup of coffee (Capricorn energy fueling my productivity), I was transported to the cobbled streets of 18th-century London, filled with dark alleys and even darker secrets.
“A woman must always know her own power, for no one else will remind her of it.”
What I Loved
This novel feels like opening a forgotten apothecary bottle—it’s full of intrigue, carefully layered with themes of revenge, empowerment, and sisterhood. Penner does a fantastic job of intertwining Nella’s gritty, dangerous life in 1791 with Caroline’s contemporary journey of self-discovery.
Each storyline felt equally compelling, and the atmosphere was so vivid I could practically smell the herbs and potions in Nella’s shop.
“The tiniest dose of poison could change everything, but so could a single act of kindness.”
What I Didn’t Love
While I loved the dual timelines, I found myself slightly more captivated by the historical sections. Caroline’s story, while relatable, occasionally felt like it dragged compared to the high stakes of Nella’s world. That said, both narratives ultimately tied together in a satisfying way.
“History is full of forgotten women who deserved to be remembered.”
Final Thoughts
This book is a love letter to women reclaiming their power. It’s about the choices we make, the bonds we form, and the secrets we keep. It also delves into the idea of legacy – what we lave behind, and how our stories are told.
This book is for:
- Fans of dual-timeline historical fiction
- Readers who love stories about women supporting women
- Anyone who enjoys a hint of mystery and a dash of feminism in their novels
The Lost Apothecary is a beautifully atmospheric tale that celebrates the resilience and strength of women across centuries. With its rich details and empowering themes, it’s perfect for readers who enjoy uncovering the hidden stories of the past.
4 out 5 stars from me!
What’s your favorite book with dual timelines? Let’s swap recommendations!